EcomBiz.AI

Join Waitlist

Order Routing Logic: Lowest Cost vs Fastest Delivery

As ecommerce businesses scale across Amazon, Walmart Marketplace, eBay, and their own storefronts, one of the most critical backend decisions is how to route orders efficiently. Do you prioritize the lowest cost supplier to protect your margins, or do you choose the fastest delivery option to satisfy increasingly impatient customers?

This article breaks down the tradeoffs and best practices in designing smart order routing logic using automation tools like EcomBiz.AI.

Why Order Routing Logic Matters

Your routing logic directly impacts:

  • Profit margins
  • Delivery times
  • Customer satisfaction and retention
  • Marketplace metrics (e.g., late shipment rate penalties on Amazon)

Inefficient routing = overspending, missed SLAs, or stockouts.

Option 1: Lowest Cost Supplier Logic

This logic prioritizes profit by routing each order to the supplier offering the lowest total fulfillment cost (product + shipping).

✅ Pros:

  • Maximizes margins
  • Reduces total cost of goods sold (COGS)
  • Ideal for low-ticket or high-volume products

❌ Cons:

  • May result in slower shipping times
  • Risk of customer complaints on marketplaces with strict delivery windows

When to Use:

  • Your buyers are price-sensitive
  • Shipping speed is not a primary purchase driver
  • You offer extended delivery expectations (like 7-10 days)

Option 2: Fastest Delivery Supplier Logic

This logic routes orders based on expected delivery speed, often leveraging suppliers closer to the customer’s zip code.

✅ Pros:

  • Faster delivery = higher customer satisfaction
  • Better seller ratings and lower return rates
  • Higher Buy Box win rate (especially on Amazon)

❌ Cons:

  • May involve higher shipping or item costs
  • Profit margins can shrink on tight-budget SKUs

When to Use:

  • You sell on marketplaces with strict delivery SLAs (Amazon, Walmart)
  • Your category demands speed (e.g., gifts, perishables, urgent items)
  • You offer Prime-like delivery guarantees

Hybrid Logic: Smart Routing with Automation

The best strategy for multichannel sellers? Let AI handle both.
EcomBiz.AI enables rule-based routing logic such as:

  • If order margin > $X, prioritize fastest delivery
  • If shipping ZIP matches certain states, use regional supplier
  • If item is backordered, reroute to alternate supplier

You can also set supplier preference hierarchies, fallback rules, and custom filters per sales channel.

Key Considerations

  • Marketplace SLAs: Amazon’s late shipment penalties can cost your account health.
  • Returns & Refunds: Delays often result in cancellations or chargebacks.
  • Customer Expectations: Speed matters more for higher-priced or last-minute purchases.
  • Stock Levels: Lowest cost supplier doesn’t help if the item is OOS.

Final Thoughts

There’s no universal “right” answer—but there is a smarter one:
Use intelligent routing automation that adapts per order, per customer, per SKU.

With tools like EcomBiz.AI, your routing logic can evolve beyond binary decisions and balance speed, cost, and customer satisfaction dynamically.

→ Ready to streamline your fulfillment process? Join the Waitlist

Table of Contents